Add up the masses of two protons and two neutrons and compare with a helium nucleus. The helium nucleus is lighter. The missing mass has not vanished: it left as energy when the nucleus formed, and the same energy must be supplied to pull the nucleus apart again.
Mass defect and binding energy
Binding energy B = Δm c² = Δm × 931.5 MeV (Δm in u)
1 atomic mass unit (u) is equivalent to 931.5 MeV of energy. In practice atomic masses are used, with the electron masses cancelling in the difference.
The curve
Plot binding energy per nucleon (B/A) against mass number A. The curve rises quickly for light nuclei, peaks near iron-56 at about 8.8 MeV per nucleon, and then falls slowly to about 7.6 MeV for uranium-235. Three facts follow:
1. The most stable nuclei sit near the peak, around A = 56.
2. Light nuclei (A below about 56) release energy when they fuse. This is nuclear fusion, as in the Sun.
3. Heavy nuclei (A above about 56) release energy when they split. This is nuclear fission, as in a reactor.
Why the curve falls on the right
The strong nuclear force acts only between close neighbours, but the electric repulsion between protons acts over the whole nucleus and grows with the number of protons. In heavy nuclei the repulsion wins a little, and B/A drops. On the left, small nuclei have many nucleons on the surface with fewer neighbours, so B/A is low.
Mistakes to avoid
Confusing total binding energy with binding energy per nucleon, forgetting the factor 931.5 when the mass is in u, and saying that fusion and fission are opposite processes with opposite energy signs. Both release energy, because both move towards the peak of the curve.
More solved problems
A Li-7 nucleus (atomic mass 7.016004 u) has 3 protons and 4 neutrons. Δm = 3(1.007825) + 4(1.008665) − 7.016004 = 0.042131 u. B = 0.042131 × 931.5 ≈ 39.2 MeV, so B/A ≈ 5.6 MeV per nucleon, lower than helium.
In the reaction D + T → He-4 + n, the masses are 2.014102 u + 3.016049 u = 5.030151 u on the left and 4.002603 + 1.008665 = 5.011268 u on the right. The mass lost is 0.018883 u, so the energy released is 0.018883 × 931.5 ≈ 17.6 MeV.
1 kg of U-235 has 1000/235 × 6.022 × 10²³ ≈ 2.56 × 10²⁴ nuclei. At 200 MeV (3.2 × 10⁻¹¹ J) per fission, the energy is about 8.2 × 10¹³ J. Burning coal gives 2.4 × 10⁷ J/kg, so this equals about 3.4 million kilograms of coal.
Practice questions (with answers)
- 1 atomic mass unit is equivalent to
(a) 93.15 MeV (b) 931.5 MeV (c) 9315 MeV (d) 1.6 MeV - The binding energy per nucleon is highest for nuclei with mass number around
(a) 2 (b) 56 (c) 120 (d) 238 - Energy is released by fusion when the nuclei fused have mass number
(a) above about 56 (b) below about 56 (c) exactly 238 (d) any value - The mass of a nucleus compared with the sum of the masses of its nucleons is
(a) more (b) less (c) equal (d) unrelated - The binding energy per nucleon of helium-4 is about
(a) 1.1 MeV (b) 7.1 MeV (c) 28 MeV (d) 8.8 MeV
Show answers
- (b) 931.5 MeV.
- (b) 56, the iron region.
- (b) below about 56.
- (b) less. The difference is the mass defect.
- (b) 7.1 MeV. (28 MeV is its total binding energy.)
Common doubts
Where does the missing mass go?
It leaves as energy (radiation and kinetic energy of the products) when the nucleus forms, in line with E = Δm c². To pull the nucleus apart, the same energy has to be put back in.
Is iron really the most tightly bound nucleus?
Strictly, nickel-62 has the highest binding energy per nucleon, with iron-56 close behind. Textbooks say 'iron region' because Fe-56 has the lowest mass per nucleon and the whole peak is very flat.
Why can both fusion and fission release energy?
Both move the nuclei towards the peak of the curve, where each nucleon is more tightly bound. Going from a lower B/A to a higher B/A always releases energy.
